Showing posts with label 1999. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1999. Show all posts

Monday

Fraternity of St. Peter

ROME IS NOW MAKING IT CLEAR –
THE ARCHBISHOP WAS RIGHT ALL ALONG!

December 1, 1999

Dear Friends and Benefactors,

A flurry of recent events in Rome involving the Fraternity of St. Peter suggests that the masters of Rome may be wishing to have done with the officially approved Tridentine Mass, perhaps in time for the Conciliar Church's millennial New Advent, so long spoken of by Pope John Paul II. The Fraternity is resisting as best it can, but Rome seems to be becoming impatient.

Some but not all of these events have been evoked in previous Seminary letters. Let us give here as many of them as we can in chronological order, to bring out the pattern underlying the events: there is no reconciliation possible between the Catholic Faith and the leaders of the Conciliar Church now occupying Rome. These Romans have lost the Faith and are doing their best to stamp it out wherever they can still find it.

By way of background we must go back to the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965), where, under the decisive influence of the two liberal Popes, John XXIII and Paul VI, the mass of the Church's then 2,000 bishops fell prey to the glamorous modern error of liberalism: just let man be free, and everything will be well.

In 1969 Pope Paul VI laid hands on the Mass, and "freed" it from its ancient rite, named Tridentine from the Council of Trent when Pope Pius V codified it, but actually going much further back in time, parts even to the very beginning of the Church. Paul VI was "up-dating" the rite of the Mass, to make it also more acceptable to non-Catholics, in particular to Protestants. And since many Catholics live their religion principally through attendance at Mass, then it was Paul VI's New Order of Mass, or "Novus Ordo", which dramatically advanced the Vatican II process of transformation of millions and millions of Roman Catholics into Roman Protestants.

Now in the same 1969, Archbishop Lefebvre, a retired missionary bishop, fully realizing the danger of the Conciliar Reform to the Catholic Faith as a whole, began his Priestly Society of St. Pius X to defend the Faith by forming true priests who would as a result celebrate only the old rite of Mass. Miraculously, as he considered, he obtained in 1970 official Church approval for his little Society. So a number of the young men drawn to his Society did not follow the Archbishop for his in-depth defense of the Faith, but only for the combination he offered them, unavailable anywhere else, of priestly formation with both the Catholic Mass and Conciliar approval.

This meant through the early 1970's that as the Conciliar authorities realized what the Archbishop was up to and therefore (invalidly) dissolved his Society in 1975 and (invalidly) suspended him in 1976, so the apparent loss of official approval made many of his seminarians leave him, even if he did maintain the Tridentine Mass. However, the famous Mass at Lille in August of 1976 demonstrated that by now the Archbishop had a large popular following. The "Traditional" movement was born, and Conciliar Rome prudently backed away from any further open persecution of the Archbishop or his Society, as such persecution risked being counter-productive.

Rome keeping relatively quiet, again a number of the Archbishop's seminarians and by now priests continued to follow him because of his unique combination of the Tridentine Mass with, sort of, Conciliar approval. Despite the Archbishop's repeated condemnations of Vatican II, they still did not understand, or want to understand, the depth of his disagreement with neo-modernist Rome. That is why, when advancing old age drove the Archbishop in 1988 to consecrate without Rome's approval four of his priests as bishops to guarantee the Society's survival, otherwise in peril, these "Tridentinists", as we shall call them, appealed to Rome to provide them with the combination of Roman approval and Tridentine liturgy which the "excommunicated" Archbishop could no longer give them.

Conciliar Rome welcomed them with open arms. Because it had converted to Tridentinism? Of course not. Rather, it saw in these refugees from the Society of St. Plus X an opportunity to set up under Rome's control an alternative "Traditional" movement to keep souls away from the real Traditional movement henceforth "excommunicated" and so out of Rome's control, except by the silence and marginalisation, or calumny and scorn, which have constituted Rome's treatment of the Society ever since. However, while allowing these Tridentinists to say only the old Mass, Rome required as a condition for its acceptance of them that they recognize the "orthodoxy and validity" of Pope Paul's New Mass. Which these Tridentinists did. So Rome now had a docile decoy to pull priests and people, as it hoped, away from the uncompromising Society of St. Plus X.

Apparently the decoy worked well enough for Rome to give it 10 years of life, so that in October of 1998 St. Peter's Fraternity celebrated in Rome, with kindred organizations, its 10th anniversary. However, the popular success of this meeting of some 2,500 Tridentinists from all over the world, all putting Rome under Tridentinist pressure, seems to have aggravated the Conciliar churchmen. They had only approved Tridentinism as a step down from Catholicism to Conciliarism. Now it seemed to be serving as a step back up from Conciliarism to Catholicism. This would not do.

We come at last to the recent events. We will narrate them as briefly as possible, with brief comments.

Spring or early summer, 1999: Grave accusations against a kindred organization of St. Peter's, the Institute of Christ the King in Gricigliano, Italy, enable Rome to threaten it with an Apostolic Visit.

The Institute was founded soon after St. Peter's by a Monsignor Wach, essentially on the same basis as St. Peter's, i.e. to practice Tridentinism under Rome's control and without attacking Rome's Conciliarism.

June 11, 1999: Cardinal Medina, head of the Roman Congregation for Divine Worship, to questions of the Archbishop of Sienna, replies officially that by Church law Latin Rite priests can say only the New Mass, that the Tridentine Mass can only be said by Rome's exceptional permission, or Indult (both statements are false). Nor, the Cardinal went on, can priests say the Tridentine Mass by force of Pius V's "perpetual" permission in "Quo Primum", because what one Pope (Pies V) did, another Pope (Paul VI) can undo (true, but no Pope can undo Catholic Tradition, as Paul VI tried to do with his new-fangled Mass).

The Cardinal is clearly trying to put the brakes on Tridentinism.

July 3, 1999: The same Cardinal drops a bomb on St. Peter's Fraternity! Allegedly in reply to questions put to his Congregation, he replies in the now notorious Protocol 1411 that, firstly, any Tridentinist priest may always say the New Mass; secondly, no Tridentinist Superior can stop him from doing so; and thirdly, any Tridentinist priest may concelebrate the New Mass.

To the credit of the St. Peter's Superior General, Fr. Bisig, he had been trying to stop St. Peter's priests from sliding towards the New Mass. Here is Rome paralyzing his efforts, for Rome never intended St. Peter's to block the New Mass, quite the contrary.

July 18, 1999: A second bomb is dropped on St. Peter's, this time by Cardinal Felici of the "Ecclesia Dei" Commission, set up by Rome in 1988 to promote Rome-controlled Tridentinism. In a remarkably swift reply to complaint written only two weeks before by 16 dissident St. Peter's priests against the "Lefebvrist" direction being imposed upon St. Peter's by Fr. Bisig, the Commission writes to him that the permission previously granted for him to hold a special General Chapter in August (to stop St. Peter's from sliding) is revoked; that instead Rome will preside over a general meeting of St. Peter's in Rome in November; and that until then he can take only minor decisions for the Fraternity.

Now Fr. Bisig may accuse these 16 priests of having gone behind his back to Cardinal Felici - yet did not he himself go behind Archbishop Lefebvre's back to Cardinal Ratzinger in the mid-1980's? And he may accuse the "Ecclesia Dei" Commission of crippling his power to govern his Fraternity - yet who but he, to distance himself from the "disobedient" Archbishop, wrote "obedience to Rome" into the founding charter of St. Peter's back in 1988? In the old expression, Fr. Bisig is "hoist with his own petard" (blown up with his own bomb).

July 20 (?), 1999: Fr. Bisig writes to re-assure members and friends of St. Peter's that beneath this double blow from Rome he is doing all he can to defend their Fraternity's Tridentinism within the official Church, for the good of that Church.

But what if that Church itself determines that its good consists in ending all Tridentinism? What then can Fr. Bisig do? He himself designed St. Peter's to "obey" Rome. Truth to tell, like all Tridentinists to the left of the Society of St. Pius X and sedevacantists to its right, Fr. Bisig is basically a Fiftiesist who wants to rebuild the Church of the 1950's. But that surface Catholicism is no match for the neo-modernists in Rome. They blew it out of the water at Vatican II. The 1950's are gone for ever. Clearly, when Fr. Bisig followed the Archbishop, he never understood the depth of the Archbishop's doctrinal combat. What Tridentinists fail to grasp is that the false Mass is merely the spin-off from a much deeper and more important problem, which is doctrinal.

End July, 1999: Fr. Bisig and a companion Tridentinist leader are told in a meeting in Rome with the same high Cardinals that their Tridentinist societies rest not upon Church law but only upon Rome's gracious permission, or Indult. And they are asked how they can, if they admit that the New Mass is "orthodox and valid", so obstinately go on refusing to say it.

Indeed from when Fr. Bisig made that admission in 1988 to gain Rome's approval, what did his Tridentinism rest on? On a sentimental preference for the old liturgy? He then put the noose around his own neck. Now Rome is pulling it tight.

September 8, 1999: A large number of St. Peter's priests write a letter of support for Fr. Bisig to the same Cardinals.

But who are they taking these Cardinals for? Defenders of the Faith?? It is a lack of Faith that fails to discern in these Cardinals wolves in sheeps' clothing. Archbishop Lefebvre, by his Faith, saw from the beginning who they were, but pastorally did all he could to make them return to behaving like shepherds, until 1988, when they gave the final proof that they had no care for the sheep of Our Lord. Then he took the drastic action of the episcopal consecrations to guarantee his Society's survival, and left the rest in God's hands, which is what the Society is continuing to do.

September 26, 1999: Monsignor Wach, referred to above, sees the writing on the wall and concelebrates the New Mass with Cardinal Ratzinger in a nearby Benedictine convent.

The same Cardinal Ratzinger had written a few years previously a handsome Tridentinist preface to a re-edition of the Tridentine Missal. Now he brings Tridentinists to heel. Is there a contradiction? No. For him, explicitly, as for the Tridentinists implicitly, Tridentinism is merely a matter of sentiment. New Mass or Old Mass, depending on how you feel that day!

Early October, 1999: Fr. Bisig speaking at a Synod of Bishops in Rome on the one hand tells them his Fraternity is doing all it can do to draw souls from the Society of St. Plus X "back into the Church", but on the other hand he tells them how Tridentinism is prospering.

Did he think they wanted to hear that Tridentinism is prospering?

October 11, 12, 1999: Rome arranges a meeting between Fr. Bisig together with Fraternity leaders loyal to him, and leaders of the 16 dissident priests who appealed to Rome against his "Lefebvrism" at the end of June. For the first day the dissidents are accompanied (and supported) by Cardinal Mayer, for the second, morning by Cardinal Felici! Only on the second afternoon are the priests left alone, whereupon the meeting turns into something of a head-on clash. All that Fr. Bisig obtains is the postponement until the New Year of Rome's take-over of the General Meeting of St. Peter's previously scheduled for November.

The head-on clash was of course between the contradictory elements enshrined in St. Peter's foundation: "obedience" to neo-modernist Rome against faithfulness to the Catholic rite of Mass. How will the clash be resolved? Either Fr. Bisig comes to heel, or he will be crushed by Rome, and the same is true for St. Peter's as a whole. Rome holds all the aces, by Fr. Bisig's doing.

October 18, 1999: Cardinal Medina, for his Congregation for Divine Worship, issues a ten-point letter in reply to the multiple questions (or complaints) raised by his bomb-shell Protocol 1411 of early July. He repeats that the New Mass is the only lawful Mass for the Latin Rite, that the Tridentine Mass continues only by Indult, that diocesan bishops should be considerate of Tridentinists, but Tridentinists in return must recognize Vatican II and all its pomps and all its works. And Tridentinist priests must celebrate the New Mass for diocesan congregations where it is usual.

Thus Rome means to crush protest.

November 17, 1999: Una Voce International, a world-wide organization of lay Tridentinists, holds a meeting in Rome, no doubt mainly to protest against this crushing of Tridentinism by Rome. At this meeting Monsignor Perl, number two (?) official of the "Ecclesia Dei" Commission, reads a "Clarification" to the assembled Una Voce delegates.

The "Clarification" begins by attributing recent attacks on the "Ecclesia Dei" Commission to "ignorance of facts" and "questionable information" on the Internet. How can the Commission be blamed for working with the diocesan bishops when that is what was meant to do from the beginning? By what right are lay associations lobbying in this religious matter? The Commission has from the Pope full authority over St. Peter's Fraternity. For any Latin Rite priest there can be no such thing as a right to celebrate the Old Mass exclusively. If St. Peter's priests refuse to concelebrate the New Mass, are they not refusing communion with the mainstream Church?

Having read this "Clarification", Msgr. Perl immediately stepped down, giving the Una Voce delegates no opportunity for questions or comment. Apparently, this left them all more or less discontented.

Dear delegates of Una Voce, let us for charity, or for the sake of argument, assume there is no malice on the part of Msgr. Perl or his fellow Romans. Still, they are all in the grip of such a different understanding of the Catholic Faith from yourselves that it would be foolish for you to expect them ever to accommodate you. Far more is at stake than just Liturgy.

Then remember how, ever since Vatican II, lay protest in defense of the Faith has never availed against the juggernaut of neo-modernism operated by the Vatican II clergy. In real terms you have as laymen only one threat that can make these Roman prelates hesitate - the threat to go over, lock stock and barrel, to the Society of St. Pius X!

The direction being taken by Rome is clear as clear can be. Can anyone still not see it? If one wishes to organize the defense of the Catholic faith, there is, alas, only the Archbishop's way. One cannot put oneself under these neo-modernist Romans.

How clear-sighted the Archbishop was! What faith he had! What a gift from God he was! Rome may crush Fr. Bisig, but it could not crush the Archbishop, nor can it crush any Catholics who like him make no compromises on Truth. The Truth is master of Rome, and not Rome master of the Truth, ultimately. The Archbishop loved Rome, in the depths of his being, but still Our Lord's Truth came first. "The Truth is mighty and will prevail", and that Truth is the strength and cohesion of the Society of St. Pius X. All who seek the Truth find themselves today substantially united in holding, broadly, the Society's positions, but that is not because they are the Society's positions, it is because they happen to be the Truth.

Once again, great Archbishop, thank you, and please pray for us.

Remember also, dear friends, the Spiritual Exercises for men here at the Seminary from the evening of December 26 to the afternoon of December 30. They have been shortened by a day because of Y2K, to let everyone get home in plenty of time. On the night of December 31 at the Seminary there will be a Benediction, with the Te Deum sung on the stroke of midnight. For Christmas, remember it is forbidden to send to the Seminary Rector Christmas cards unless you first cross out the "merry" Christmas and put "scroogy" instead.

To all of you, Happy New Year, happy new decade, happy new century and happy new millennium!

Sincerely yours in Our Divine Lord, still King of Kings and Master of the Universe,

John Paul II's thinking on the meeting of Assisi

November 3, 1999

Dear Friends and Benefactors,

There is some good news from the Seminary, some not good news from Rome and some more good news from the Headquarters of the Society of St. Plus X in Menzingen, Switzerland.

The good news from the seminary is that we have had 15 young men enter as candidates for the priesthood this autumn, and there may even be a sixteenth. True, the launching in September of an extra Preliminary Year may account for half of these candidates, but in a world where each vocation amounts to a miracle, as Archbishop Lefebvre used to say, 15 vocations amount to 15 miracles. Your prayers for vocations are bearing fruit, as are the Society’s Mass Centres, Missions and Churches, from which come almost all of these vocations.

More good news from the Seminary is that this Preliminary Year is working well. It is designed to enable under-educated candidates to catch up on some studies within the Seminary surroundings before they enter the Seminary proper. The studies include mainly catechism, Latin and English, with a little History, Music and Literature. For some years now the generally falling standards of education have called for such an initiative, but only this year did Providence provide a suitable priest to handle the bulk of the extra teaching. Readers of this Letter may recognize in this Preliminary Year something like the "concentration camp" described two and a half years ago to help distracted young men to concentrate. Indeed there is a connection, but the original wide open dream has given way to a precisely seminary-oriented program. Needs must. A seminary must do a seminary's work, which is tightly directed towards the priesthood.

The bad news from Rome is the repeat in Rome itself one week ago of the 1986 Prayer meeting of World Religions in Assisi, and then the signature fast week-end of the Joint Catholic-Lutheran Declaration on Justification in Augsburg, Germany. What is going on in these churchmen's heads? What are they thinking of? What do they believe in? I can remember how back in 1986 Archbishop Lefebvre was disappointed at how few even "Traditional" Catholics were scandalized by the first Assisi meeting. What is the essential difference between the mind of the Archbishop and the mind of John Paul II, for whom that meeting was a high point, if not the high point, of his pontificate up till then?

Certainly, John Paul II has in this respect the modern world on his side. The way of thinking of the mass of people all around us, caused and reflected by the truthless media, is that all men must come together, all divisions between men are bad, and all ideas that divide men must give way to the unity of mankind. And this way of thinking has got into many Catholics' heads.

On the contrary Our Divine Lord, telling the truth (Jn XIV, 6) that his Father commanded him to tell (Jn VIII, 28) and that he came into the world to tell (Jn XVIII, 37), was willing to divide the people (Jn VII, 43) and even to lose all his apostles (Jn VI, 68) if that had to be the result of his telling the truth. Obviously Our Lord wanted to lose neither his apostles (Jn XVII, 11) nor the people (Jn III; 16), but there could be no question of his Father's interests (and commands) not coming first (Jn XII, 49; XIV, 31, etc., etc.).

In brief, Archbishop Lefebvre and all other faithful followers of Jesus Christ put God, and the First Commandment, first. On the contrary the modern world and all those who follow it, put men, and the unity of men, first. But how can leading Catholic churchmen, in theory followers of Our Lord Jesus Christ, come to follow the world in practice?

Through any one or all of several causes working together. Let us name a few. Firstly, lack of true prayer which keeps a soul in the truth and wanting or loving the truth. Secondly, pride which makes men want to take the place of God, and which is at the heart of, thirdly, modern philosophy which so corrupts men's minds as to confuse and dissolve altogether their grasp on any objective truth, even if they mean well, as John Paul II gives many signs of doing.

The good news from Menzingen is the letter written to the Pope by our Superior General, Bishop Bernard Fellay, on the occasion of this repeat of Assisi. As Our Lord said, if his disciples were silenced, the stones of the street would rise up to tell the truth (Lk. XIX, 4L1).

Patience, dear readers. The Lord God will not be silenced. Pray through November for the Holy Souls who can also cry out for us.

Most sincerely yours in Our Lord,

Confusion in Newchurch disguises drive towards destruction of faith

October 4, 1999

Dear Friends and Benefactors,

Confusion continues to pour out of the churchmen now governing the Catholic Church in Rome, but, however good their intentions may sometimes seem to be, the end result every time is the destruction of the Church. By a just judgment of God, His enemies have acquired firm control over the levers of Church power — for the time being.

As someone once said of American foreign policy in the wake of World War II, if only occasionally it had failed to advance Communism one might have thought it promoted it by accident or by stupidity, but when that policy's effect was to promote Communism every single time, then one knew that that had to be its deliberate aim. If only occasionally these churchmen would effectively defend the Faith, one might think that its destruction was not their deliberate aim, but as it is...

The parallel is appropriate. Just as the liberals who promoted Communism were convinced they were rendering the world a service and root a disservice (which is why Alger Hiss, the famous 1940's adversary of Whittaker Chambers, emotionally repudiated his factual qualification as "liar" and "traitor" until the day he died), so the churchmen now promoting ecumenism are convinced they are rendering the Church a service, and on their death-bed they will still be convinced of it. Which is why they are so confusing as well as confused. Let us attempt to restore clarity in two cases current.

The first case is no doubt familiar to many of you: the recent moves made by Rome to strangle Tradition within the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter. See the enclosed flyer for a very brief account of the moves, and for an extensive evaluation from "Alice through the Looking-Glass"! Yes, there is more sense in a few pages out of Alice's Wonderland than in volumes and volumes coming out of this Rome!

The truth is, as a few of the Roman liberals openly admitted from the beginning, that they only granted official status to St. Peter's in 1988 as a means of getting "Traditional" Catholics back into their Newchurch, to divide and rule the Catholic resistance. Poor St. Peter's! Could they not see that if they wanted to defend Catholicism, this Rome would never allow them to succeed? That if they succeeded they could not survive, and that if they survived they could not succeed?

No, St. Peter's did not see it. Instead of judging conciliar Rome as a whole by its consistently disastrous fruits, they wanted to judge it by this or that still Catholic part within the disastrous whole. But when a whole is no longer Catholic, then any parts still Catholic within that whole merely serve to deceive. St. Peter's is now paying the penalty for letting themselves be deceived. Maybe even now they can rouse sufficient Catholic resistance within the Newchurch to obtain a reprieve, but the death-warrant of Tradition amongst them has clearly been signed. It is only a matter of time.

The second case of how apparent confusion in the Newchurch merely disguises its relentless drive towards the destruction of the Catholic Faith is the last two years' dance of Roman documents on the dogmatic question of Justification, which is the question of how a human soul is moved from the state of sin into the state of grace or of justice before God.

To this question about 1600 years ago St. Augustine, the "Doctor of Grace", formulated, under pressure from heretics, the Catholic answer. About 470 years ago Luther set up an answer so different that it became one of the major differences dividing true Protestants from true Catholics ever since. About 30 years ago in the wake of Vatican II, "ecumenism" demanded that Catholics and Protestants get together. So discussions between them began, due to culminate at the end of this month (October 30, 31) in an official joint signing in Augsburg, Germany, of a "squarcular" document, wherein the Catholics will declare that the Catholic square is a squarcle, while the Protestants will declare that the protestant circle is a squarcle! So everybody will be agreed, and ecumenism will have scored another squarcular triumph! (Augsburg is where the Protestants came together on June 25, 1530 to sign a joint Protestant creed! October 31 is the day on which 482 years ago Luther posted his "95 Theses" against the Papacy!)

In pursuit of clarity, let us back up. Let us see, however briefly, Catholic doctrine and the Protestant error (and its gravity) before we go dancing with the ecumenists! Such a deep question of doctrine as justification requires precision of detail to be treated properly, but what follows may have to blur some details in order to pick out the grand outlines.

Firstly, let us recall Catholic doctrine on the mode, effect and fruits of grace justifying a soul, or making it just before God. As to its mode, the Catholic Church has always taught that while supernatural grace can only come from God to move a man's soul to justice, nevertheless man being a rational creature with free will, it is not fitting that he should be merely moved by God with no participation of his own, so in fact he will not be justified by God's grace unless he freely assents to its moving him, and co-operates with it doing so. As to grace's effect, the Catholic Church has always taught that if a man does thus assent to grace moving his soul to justice, then his soul will be essentially cleansed of sin, both original (if not yet cleansed) and all personal sin, leaving in the soul only "concupiscence" or that inclination to sin which is the weakness Adam bequeathed to all of us, but which is not sin in the proper sense because an inclination is not an act. So for Catholics grace truly cleanses the soul and the sinner is truly justified. Finally, as to grace's fruits, the Catholic Church has always taught that once the soul is constituted in this state of grace, it can perform works supernatural and meritorious before God which it could not do before, indeed it must perform such works, otherwise its faith is dead (James II, 14-26) and not working through charity (Gal. V, 6).

Against this Catholic doctrine Martin Luther protested around 1520, and launched Protestantism. For personal reasons, it is said, of having difficulty in obeying God's Commandments, he gave up the effort to change himself and set about changing Church doctrine instead. Wresting to his own purpose St. Paul's teaching of "Justification by Faith" (Galatians, Romans), Luther taught that as to grace's mode, it justifies man by moving his breast to a warm feeling of trust in God, but in that process man's free will is so weak or non-existent as to be incapable of playing any part. Therefore grace alone justifies. Correspondingly, as to its effect, justifying grace for Luther does not clean all sin out of the essence of a justified man's soul, rather the filth of sin remains in his soul while the grace of Christ's merits is put like a lid over the top of the soul to cover the filth remaining beneath. Accordingly as to the fruits of grace, Luther teaches that a man "justified" in this way need not do any good works (from a still filthy soul, how could he?), all he need do is "believe", i.e. work up that warm feeling in his breast. Hence Luther's famous saying "Sin much, just believe still more" ("Pecca fortiter, sed crede fortius").

This Lutheran doctrine is (objectively) horrible. It is tailor-made to justify a man's wallowing in his sin, as it cuts off all real demands or true supernatural grace to get him out of it. It "liberates" him from the Ten Commandments, and founds all liberalism, Revolution, separation of Church and State, etc., etc.. It reduces religion to mere emotions and cosy feelings, cutting it off from real life, founding all subjectivism, "Sunday Catholicism", the turning of feelings into facts, etc., etc.. No wonder from the Council of Trent onwards, the Catholic Church vigorously and precisely condemned Luther's literally filthy version of justification (Session VI).

But finally came Vatican II (1962-1965) with its "ecumenism" opening up the Catholic Church to all other "religions" and to their errors, especially Protestantism. In 1997 the discussions between Catholic and Protestant squarclers finally led to a "Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification" (JDDJ) which concludes (#40) that "a consensus in basic truths of the doctrine of justification exists between Lutherans and Catholics"!

The squarcling technique of the Declaration is to reduce both Catholic and Protestant doctrine on a given point to their highest common factor, and then give on that common factor a Catholic spin more or less acceptable to Lutherans, and, separately, a Lutheran spin more or less acceptable to Catholics. For ecumenical purposes, it is a clever technique, and the Lutheran World Federation swiftly approved of the Joint Declaration.

However, in June of last year the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity prepared by common agreement and published a "Catholic Response to the JDDJ" (CR) which, amidst any defects it may have, nevertheless exposes serious doctrinal problems in the JDDJ. Mode: man is not "merely passive" when moved by grace (CR #3). Effect: sin does not "still live" in the soul justified (CR #1). Fruits: good works are the fruit of grace but also, as is not clear from the JDDJ, "of man justified and interiorly transformed" (CR #3).

Somebody in Rome still has some Catholic doctrine in him! So what does Rome do? On June 11 of this year in Geneva, the Secretary General of the Lutheran World Federation and Cardinal Cassidy, President of the Pontifical Council for the Promotion of Christian Unity presented an official joint "Annex" to the JDDJ which blandly over-rides the doctrinal objections of CR by re-affirming the squarcular ambiguities of JDDJ. And the "Annex" claims, like JDDJ, that this squarcular doctrine falls under none of the Catholic condemnations of Protestant error (notably at the Council of Trent), nor under old Protestant "condemnations" of Catholic doctrine.

Logically, media reports on the publication of this Annex with the JDDJ concluded that the Catholic Church and Protestant communities were repudiating their past. For instance, Catholics had to be giving up the dogmatic anti-Protestant definitions of the Council of Trent. Oh no, said Rome. On June 22 a press statement was issued from Cardinal Cassidy's Council which can only be called another piece of ecumenical doubletalk: the JDDJ does not fall under Trent's condemnations, but those condemnations are as serious as ever, as "salutary warnings". Yet how can a "salutary warning" be as serious as a dogmatic condemnation? Clearly, ecumenism rots Catholic minds. Freemasons within the Vatican are relentlessly destroying the Catholic Church.

For the repeat Assisi-style ecumenical meeting planned in Rome for the end of this month prior to the Augsburg signing, the Society of St. Pius X's Superior General is calling for Society Chapels to hold ceremonies of reparation at the same time (Details in the USA from the SSPX HQ in Kansas City). And, to encourage you, dear readers, for the new Seminary school-year the Lord God has sent us over a dozen promising young men.

Not all is lost. We count on, and are always grateful for, your continuing support.

Most sincerely yours in Our Lord,

Bishop Thomas' response to letter sent out by SSPX in France

September 1, 1999

Dear Friends and Benefactors,

It is not often that anybody high in the official Church undertakes to argue with the Society of St. Pius X, but it is revealing when they do. Each time it reveals, contrary to pious hopes and dangerous illusions, just how far apart in their thinking are the Society and the mainstream Church. Let us look at the argument of a mainstream bishop who attempted earlier this year to meet the Society on its own ground — Catholic Tradition.

Bishop Jean-Charles Thomas of the Diocese of Versailles near Paris was responding to a circular letter sent out by the Society's District in France to some 20,000 Novus Ordo priests (yet he would accuse the Society of being closed in on itself). Here is the substance of his response:

He begins by recognizing that everybody, priests or laity, is "deeply convinced" that the Second Vatican Council was a "turning point", or "change", in the Church. The only question is whether this change is "a betrayal of the Church", as the Society claims, or "a return to a greater fidelity to Tradition", as (he says) the mainstream churchmen claim. And the answer to that question depends upon one's scheme of reference.

The Society's scheme of reference is certain writings of Popes between 1850 and 1950, forming "a brief, limited and recent source" of Catholic Tradition, lasting only 100 years, by which source the Vatican II change stands condemned. On the contrary the official churchmen's scheme of reference is all of Scripture, Old and New Testaments, especially God's Revelation through Christ, continually being renewed by the Holy Ghost in "a living Tradition now 20 centuries old".

These two schemes of reference, says Bishop Thomas, generate two very different versions of Catholicism. On the basis of its one-century Tradition, the Society neglects Scripture, Church Fathers and early Councils. It involves few souls and only their personal salvation. It leaves out mankind and the salvation of the world, and it glorifies Pope and priests at the expense of Bishops and laity. On the contrary Vatican II's 20-century Tradition means "the Good News of Salvation being put before all mankind", i.e. it means re-connecting with Bible, Church Fathers and early Councils, and it involves all men without exception and the world's salvation, in the wake of all the Church's great Founders of Orders and in line with the Holy Ghost "renewing the face of the earth" to the end of time.

Bishop Thomas concludes that whereas the Society's Catholicism is narrow, shut in on itself, out of touch with today's world and condemnatory, Vatican II is wide open, apostolic, contemporary and salvatory, or, aiming to save men instead of condemn them. So he hails Vatican II ecumenism with its joyful prospect of uniting "the children of God, presently so divided"!

In brief, Bishop Thomas wishes to take the word "Tradition" away from the Traditionalists, on the grounds that it is Vatican II and not Archbishop Lefebvre or the Society of St. Pius X that is in line with the first 1800 years of Church teaching and history. Let us check this argument against the facts and against Catholic doctrine.

Firstly, as to the facts it is easy to dismiss both Bishop Thomas' caricature of the society's Catholicism and his rosy picture of the Vatican II religion. For instance, was Archbishop Lefebvre "narrow" when for 15 years to build up the Society he traveled all over the world to visit, confirm, and ordain? Was he "shut in on himself" when from 1970 to 1988 he kept going down to Rome, without being heard, to plead for the Church? Was he "out of touch with today's world" when in 1988 he had 300 journalists falling over one another to get a view and report on his episcopal consecrations? And was he "condemnatory" when he thus exhausted his old age to save souls? As for the Society, his relatively young disciples may not be up to his level, but who can deny they are doing what they can to imitate his world-wide striving for the salvation of souls?

Measured likewise against the facts, Bishop Thomas' glamorous portrait of the Vatican II religion is simply unreal. That religion is putting in front of men not Christ's Salvation which requires penance, baptism and living to die in the state of grace, but an old error of Universal Salvation whereby everybody is saved, regardless of their religion or way of life (see the four volumes of Professor Dormann's "Theological Journey of John-Paul II to the Prayer Meeting of Religions in Assisi"). Correspondingly, the Vatican II religion falsifies Bible, Church Fathers, etc. Nor does it follow the great Founders of Catholic Orders — we have been reminded recently how Padre Pio blasted in the name of St. Francis the up-dated Franciscans trying to win him over to the revolutionizing of their Order. And who can without blasphemy ascribe to the Holy Ghost the fruits of Vatican II ? — collapsed Mass attendance, disintegrating families, empty seminaries and convents, closed schools, decimated dioceses, etc., etc.!

Now it is true that there was a serious problem in the Catholic Church in the 1950's just prior to Vatican II, as there was in the 1520's, just prior to the Reformation: the Catholicism of too many Catholics had become hollow and external, like a husk without a kernel. But then as now the solution was not that of Luther or Vatican II and Bishop Thomas, to throw out the husk as well. The true solution was that of the great Saints of the Counter-Reformation, to renew the inner kernel and put vigorous life back beneath the husk, which is what Archbishop Lefebvre did, as far as he could, in our own day.

Alas, Vatican II has all the power of a dream to bewitch men's minds and to make modernists like Bishop Thomas incapable of recognizing facts. Will any amount of ruins persuade him that Vatican II was a failure? One may doubt it. Nor is he any more real when it comes to Catholic doctrine, which he similarly presses into the service of his dream. Let us look at his argument on Tradition.

He recognizes that Catholic Tradition cannot change, because it is the deposit of the Faith, entrusted to the Church by our Lord Jesus Christ to be preserved by it intact until the end of time. But he also admits — dangerous admission for a liberal — that Vatican II was a change from what went before. Therefore to avoid admitting that Vatican II broke with Tradition, he must claim that what came before Vatican II had previously broken with Tradition, so that he can then claim, as he does, that Vatican II was a change back to Tradition. This supposed previous break he makes, naturally, as recent as he can, in order to give as little weight as possible to the great anti-liberal Encyclicals of the Popes prior to Vatican II. So he supposes the previous break around 1850.

Actually, the series of those encyclicals began at the latest in 1832, with Gregory XVI's "Mirari Vos", or even in 1791, with Pius VI's authoritative condemnation of the principles of the French Revolution of 1789. But let that detail pass. The problem for Bishop Thomas is that these papal documents solemnly condemn, anywhere from 50 to 100 years in advance of Vatican II, the liberal principles which are at the heart of the Vatican II "change". That is why Bishop Thomas is forced to claim that these Encyclicals are out of line with all previous Church teaching, so that he can claim that he is the one that is faithful to Tradition.

But Bishop Thomas is "out of the frying-pan into the fire". For indeed the briefest study of those Encyclicals, notably Pius IX's "Quanta Cura" and "Syllabus", and Pius X's "Pascendi" and "Lamentabili", shows that those Popes not only declared that their anti-liberal doctrine was the purest continuation into 19th and 20th century circumstances of the previous 18 centuries of Church teaching, but also they put the full force of their papal authority behind that anti-liberal doctrine as being the Church's unchanged teaching (see the enclosed flyer on "Quanta Cura"). Then if Bishop Thomas claims that the anti-liberal Encyclicals are outside Tradition, he has to claim that, amongst others, Pius IX and Pius X, a declared Servant of God and a canonized Saint respectively, did not know what they were talking about. But in that case why should any Catholic Pope know what he is talking about, including the Vatican II Popes? Then why be Catholic?

In other words, either Popes Pius IX and Pius X were right, in which case Vatican II is wrong, and one must follow Catholic Tradition in the true sense of Archbishop Lefebvre and not in the false sense of Bishop Thomas. Or Popes Pius IX and X were wrong in claiming that their Encyclicals contained unchanged and unchangeable Catholic doctrine, in which case Popes Paul VI and John-Paul II might just as easily be wrong in anything they claim, in which case there is no reason to be a Catholic. In brief, the choice is between either Archbishop Lefebvre's Catholicism (which of course is not his), or the Church's disintegration. Is this alternative not what we see taking shape all around us?

Cardinal Ratzinger's solution to the problem (problem for liberals) of those anti-liberal Encyclicals was to call them "substantial anchorages" in Church doctrine and history. In other words they were good (substantial) teaching for their own time, but the Bark of Peter could no more reasonably stay at anchor with them for ever than any ship can be expected to stay at one anchorage for ever. New century, new anchorages, new doctrinal Encyclicals. But that does not solve the problem either, because Pius IX and Pius X solemnly declared that they were teaching not truths substantial for their own age, but doctrine unchangeably true for all time. If they were right, Vatican II is wrong. If they were wrong, we disintegrate as Catholics. Ah, but they were half-right and half-wrong, says the artful Cardinal. That is why we see him half-Catholic and half-disintegrating!

The truth about these Encyclicals is that just as the arrival of Protestantism in the early 1500's created new circumstances for the Church requiring the re-statement, not change, of Catholic doctrine by new Doctors such as St. Robert Bellarmine to meet the new errors, and from then on nobody could reject his teaching (except on minor points or novelties) and still claim to be Catholic, so the mutation of Protestantism into Liberalism around the early 1800's, in the wake of the French Revolution, required new Encyclicals from the Popes to re-state in the new circumstances the unchanged Catholic doctrine, and all those who like Cardinal Ratzinger or Bishop Thomas reject those Encyclicals denounce themselves as liberals and cannot claim to be Catholic. They are refusing the anchorage of absolute truth. Their minds are, ultimately, at sea. Ultimately, they have no idea of what it is to be a Catholic. And such men are in control of the structures of the Church!

Dear readers, pray for your part that the minds of Society priests (and bishops!) never slip anchor until God restores the Pope and Rome, not necessarily in Rome! And according to possibilities, study those Encyclicals which Archbishop Lefebvre loved and taught for exactly the same reason that Bishop Thomas rejects them - they are the most brief, profound and authoritative refutation of the errors presently savaging the Catholic Church. See advertised on the next Seminary Tapes flyer audio- and video-tapes of doctrinal Sessions held here from 1995 to 1997, precisely on those Encyclicals ("Pascendi" 1996, "Quanta Cura" 1997). Contrary to what Bishop Thomas thinks, we hold their doctrine to be indispensable not just to our own salvation, but to that of the entire world.

Most sincerely yours in Our Lord,

What is going wrong with our children?

July 1, 1999

Dear Friends and Benefactors,

Ever since the April 20 school shooting in Littleton, Colorado, anguished Americans have been asking themselves, "What has gone wrong with our children? What has gone wrong with out culture?" Dear Americans, you have no hope of finding the real answer until you ask, "What has gone wrong with our religion?"

The Colorado shooting was merely the latest and bloodiest in a series of shootings that have burst out in schools all over the United States in the last few years. This time 12 school-children were killed, many more injured, and one adult teacher died. Then the two killers, apparently normal and good-looking boys of 17 and 18 years of age from a wealthy white Denver suburb, having turned their school into a slaughter-house filled with smoke and blood and corpses, turned their guns on themselves. What is the problem?

All the Liberals and liberal politicians have used Littleton to clamour for more gun control laws. Now every such advance in tyranny may well be deserved by a people rendering themselves otherwise ungovernable, but gun control remains the stupidest of solutions to Littleton - Americans gained their Republic by guns, and they have kept their guns at home for over 200 years without their children serially killing one another. Obviously the problem is not the guns, but the mentality of whoever handles them. Where does the murderous mentality come from?

A less stupid but still relatively shallow solution is to blame the young minds' being formed to murder on the violence everywhere to be found in Hollywood films, television and computer games. True, these are filled with violence but they do not - yet - drive many people to actually killing. If so many suburbanites are presently wallowing in such fantasy violence, is it not because they have achieved their high degree of security and comfort only by eliminating from their Dilbertian existence so much of life and interest that they need the fantasy violence to even feel alive? Yet the more they are thus entertained, are they not the more deep down bored? Then rather than blame the killers on the video-games, would it not be truer to blame both killers and video-games on the nature of today's big-city or suburban way of life which is so dissatisfying for human beings? We should be getting warmer, because instead of blaming things, we are beginning to situate the problem where all real human problems belong, in the sinful human heart. But what is sinful about suburban culture?

For a start, the public schools which generate a good deal of that culture. Write to "Summit Journal", P.O. Box 207, Manitou Springs, Colorado 80829, USA, for an admirable analysis in the June issue of how, if one wanted to produce school-killers, the present curriculum in American public schools could hardly have been better designed! The author, Dr. David Noebel, knows what he is talking about. Over years he has built up a highly effective organization to counter-act the public schools' godlessness, by teaching the anti-modern principles of Protestant godliness to adolescents otherwise defenseless against the skilful perversion wrought upon their minds and hearts by these schools which, as far as education goes, have become organized treachery. Some instinct that this is so surely explains in part why the Littleton killers took out their rage on their school.

However, if school-killers had healthy — truly healthy — homes, would even the betrayal they undergo at school inspire in them such murderous rage? Surely not. Surely in this respect the real evil of suburban or modern culture is what it has done to the family and to the home. For years — you readers should know — this Letter has here been trying to make the alarm-bell ring off the wall. It has resorted to "shocking" language (dreams not dry), "shocking" people (Una-bomber), "shocking" musicians (Pink Floyd), "shocking" condemnations (the "Sound of Music" is way out of tune) and "shocking" facts (children of either sex being commonly violated at home by their own fathers "But, mummy, you dress like that!"), in order to punch some reality into Catholic minds, where it belongs. (Bless you, dear readers, easily most of you have already signed up to continue being punched, despite the faintly sharp challenge to do so, written by me, only signed by Mrs. Mehren! She is innocent!)

Here is more of the same. In the last few days we learned (not in the confessional) of the case of a 15-year old girl here in small-town Winona being repeatedly violated and finally impregnated by her drunken father, who to all appearances, sincerely! - claims he has no idea what he was doing! Mother worked the night-shift, perhaps to avoid his drinking, so she too claims she has no idea what was going on! The girl, helped to flee to a foster-home in a mid-size town nearby, took her 13-year old sister with her in the hope of continuing to protect her (all that these children have is one another!), only to discover there that the little sister shares her condition! America, WAKE UP! YOUR CHILDREN ARE SCREAMING!

I am sorry, readers, but if you want a Minnie Mouse religion, you should not be Catholics. The guardian of the foster-home said (but how much longer will there be any sane adults to provide guardians?), "Imagine how much more of this there is in our mid-size town, let alone in the big cities!" Imagine also the rage in the heart of the older girl, who is convinced she let down her little sister! Now, in home dramas of this kind, or in the whole culture that generates them, is there not the proportionate explanation for the rage, for example, manifested to all the world on the web-site of the leader of the two Littleton killers...? Over generations, but especially since the demonic 1960's, modern parents have lost the art of parenting, homes are no longer true homes, and there is a devastating coldness and emptiness in the hearts of the children, hardly any more children.

What ever happened to the family? The atom is tightly bound together by natural forces, but once it is split, those forces create a devastating explosion. Natural family bonds are enormously strong, but once they are pulled apart, they wreak untold havoc. So how were grand- (and great-grand-) parents pulled apart from grandchildren when each has so much to give that is human that the other needs? How did parents largely lose the art of parenting (it can be regained), and begin treating their children like adults or babies, in any case not like children? How did husband and wife lose all sense of the difference between man and woman and of their complementary natures and needs?

Answer, the family was torn apart starting over one hundred years ago by the same false gods that had revolutionized society at large one hundred years before that: liberty, equality, human rights, democracy. If I am tied, I am not free, so freedom tears out all family ties. Equality wipes out complementarity. Democracy destroys all hierarchy or order, like children honouring parents while parents look after children, wife obeying husband while husband cherishes wife. Human rights block out human duties, especially towards God, and with no God, nothing so human as the family can go right for long. Thus the whole culture of our revolutionary society turns families into bunches of individuals merely living under the same roof. These non-homes are what makes the hearts of killers.

And where does this anti-natural worship of individualism come from, and how can it have such power? Christianity taught mankind the value of each man. Individualism run wild in modern Western society is that Christianity without Christ. Its power came from the Catholic Church, its running wild came straight from the smashing of that Church, i.e. Protestantism. If, as Luther said, I need no supernatural society such as the Catholic Church to mediate between me and my God for my eternal needs, such as justification and salvation, why should I need any natural society for any of my lesser needs? I, who deal directly with God, stand on my own!

And thus between society and the individual, although designed by God for one another, be it the Communion of Saints in Heaven or the practice of justice and charity on earth, there is introduced an unnatural dialectic, a fatal opposition, emerging clearly into view in Shakespeare's famous play "Hamlet" (to which we shall return), and surfacing in blood in Littleton. So a decent Protestant with his decency and an upright use of Scripture (which is Catholic) can work a good way back towards the true and only possible solution (which is Catholic) of the modern world's artificial clash between society and individual, between rotten school and raging killer, but to any extent that he still shares in the false worship of individualism, Lutheranism or Liberalism, to that extent he can only help to perpetuate the clash.

Dr. Noebel, you have done sterling work in arming thousands of abandoned children against the devils of their miseducation. It only remains for you to clean out the father of most of these devils — Martin Luther.

Yet what chance does a Dr. Noebel have of discerning today what the Catholic Church truly teaches about Luther, when the Vatican itself is making a Joint Declaration with Lutherans to say they have come to an agreement, and is then issuing a Clarification of the Declaration to say it is not an agreement? What confusion! But that is the subject of another letter. Doctor, all I can say meanwhile is that the Catholic Church today is like Our Lord carrying his Cross. On that Way of the Cross, how difficult it would have been to recognize him as God, but true God he still was!

Patience, dear readers. Our Catholic Faith is our victory over all the problems around us, and it is our launching-pad for an eternity of bliss.

Most sincerely yours in Our Lord,

What is happening in Yugoslavia?

May 5, 1999

Dear Friends and Benefactors,

What is going on in Yugoslavia? Why on earth has a coalition of NATO nations, with the USA in the lead, been reducing Serbia to rubble with week after week of relentless aerial bombardment? In defense of human rights? To defend a people, you smash their country to pieces? You have to believe the media to believe that!

Then what is going on? It is time to ask. Firstly, if the poltroons who command the Western "democracies" commit the ultimate folly of engaging a ground war in Serbia, then at latest when the body-bags begin coming home, "patriotism" will shut down minds, and clear thinking will become, if not impossible, at least unsayable.

Secondly, modern wars are never what they are made to seem, and Catholics must be careful how their "patriotism" gets engaged. For instance, many American Catholics, by embracing heart and soul the great liberal crusade of World War II, came out of the war with their Catholicism so wedded to liberalism that they fell easy prey to Fiftiesism and Vatican II, with the loss of millions of their souls. "My country, right or wrong" is not only foolish in this life, it is downright dangerous for eternal life. "Patriotism is not enough", said Nurse Edith Cavell.

Then what is happening in Yugoslavia? War is always a consequence of sin, as the Apostle James (IV, 1) tells us, so we know that in one way or another the justice of God is being wrought there upon sins of men in general (Medjugorje?). But who is sinning in particular? Of course the liberals and their vile media are telling us that the Americans are saints and the Serbians are devils. But when we recall that exactly the same liberals and media, now screeching like hawks and waving the flag, were, over Vietnam, screeching like doves (some doves!) and burning the flag, we smell a rat. What is going on?

Any war, like any divorce, is a complicated and messy affair, with the fault rarely being on one side only. Because of historical circumstances, Yugoslavia is a particularly complicated part of the world, riddled with tensions and bitterness and ancient hatreds. All the more reason, one would have thought, for NATO not to get in the middle of local conflicts! What on earth does it think it is doing?

A wise commentator, not a Catholic but a nationalist, has a good part of the answer. Let us call him E.Z. for easy reference. He tells how, from the beginning of the Western nations' onslaught upon Serbia, he could make no sense of what he was hearing and seeing of the endless destruction, until several weeks later when the NATO spokesman in Brussels, a Jamie Shea, explained: What was at stake in Yugoslavia was the upholding of multi-ethnic, multi-cultural, multi-religious societies and thus of modern states, into the next century and the new millennium.

Now it was clear, writes E.Z.. The artificial and anti-natural "nations" constructed on the revolutionary basis of the Secret Societies' "Liberty, Equality, Fraternity", must be preserved and upheld by guns and bombs. That is why the Serbian leader Milosevic was perfectly acceptable to the New World Order so long as his repression and crimes were serving to protect the artificial construct known as "Yugoslavia", but as soon as Milosevic realized from a visit to Kosovo in 1993 that the Muslim immigrants in Kosovo, which is historically sacred to Serbia, risked taking it over by their superior birth-rate, so that he began defending the natural nation of Serbia for the Serbians, then he instantly became the new Hitler-of-the-day, like Saddam and Khadafi before him. Likewise, what U.S. officials had branded as a "terrorist organization" changed overnight into Kosovo's "Liberation Army"!

Thus for E.Z., NATO here represents artificial internationalism waging ruthless war upon what still remains of natural nationalism. Why NATO? Because its recent expansion makes it for the internationalists a more suitable instrument of control than their other artificial pipe-dream, the United Nations, which has failed them too often lately. Not enough of the little nations represented in the UN are yet sufficiently de-natured to be blind to the crushing threat hanging over all of them if NATO's murderous meddling in the internal affairs of Serbia is successful.

E.Z. adds various possible secondary motives for the onslaught in Yugoslavia. These are useful to understand the modern world. Amongst others are the need for war to prevent the world economy from falling into a depression only World War II and not the New Deal pulled the USA out of the Great Depression of the 1930's); the need for industrialists to make billions of dollars from replacing the planes and missiles reducing Serbia to rubble, and for the international megacorporations to make billions more out of rebuilding from the rubble; the need for the military to test their high-tech hard-ware in action; the need maybe for masses of rubble to warn the Red Army in Russia of what could happen to them if they dare to rise up against the New World Order gangsters presently ruining their country; the need for the same gangsters to get control of what is known to be Kosovo's fabulous underground mineral wealth.

Howsoever it be with these secondary motives for the NATO onslaught, E.Z. is surely right as to the primary motive: the exemplary crushing of the last remains of nationalism by Judeo-masonry's New World Order internationalism. But there remain for a complete understanding of events in the Balkans (and in many other places) two major questions which must escape the best of nationalists: why must the New World Order smash natural nationalism, and how can it be succeeding in a purpose so unnatural? Only a Catholic can answer these questions because they involve Jesus Christ, King of the Nations such as only Catholics believe Him to be.

We must back-track to the Middle Ages, the high-point of Christendom, when Christian civilization was largely Catholic and when all Christians acknowledged Jesus Christ (at least in principle) as King of kings and Lord of lords (Apoc. XVII, 14). At that time Christendom consisted of a family of nations, each with its distinct identity, yet all enjoying together Christian unity. By contrast nationalism preserves the identity (eg. Serbia for the Serbians) but it destroys the unity (Serbia against Croatia against Bosnia, etc.), whereas internationalism restores a certain unity (League of Nations, United Nations) while dissolving identity (in multi-ethnic, multi-cultural, multi-religious constructs). How did Christendom achieve simultaneously both the nations' identity and their unity?

Because Our Divine Lord does for nations what He does for individuals. Just as, for an individual, "Whosoever will save his life, shall lose it: and whosoever shall lose his life for My sake and the gospel, shall save it" (Mk VIII, 35), so too for a nation. If (at least since Christ) a nation seeks its identity outside of Christ, it is heading for destruction or for loss of identity in liberalism, whereas if in pursuit of Christ it renounces any self-fulfillment it holds dear, not only will it discover its true identity in Christ, i.e. whatever God meant that nation to be, but it will simultaneously achieve automatic harmony and unity with all other nations likewise "losing" themselves in Christ. In other words Our Lord says to the nations what he says to persons, "Seek ye first the kingdom of God, and His justice, and all these things shall be added unto you" (Mt. VI, 33).

Thus within medieval Christendom, nations enjoyed, as never before or since, both particular identity and general unity. But this was only possible in Jesus Christ. As soon as the nations began to turn away from him, then to preserve their identity they lost their unity - that was nationalism with its unprecedentedly terrible wars, like World War I, or, if the nations still would not learn their lesson but persisted in their apostasy, then they recovered an artificial unity by trashing their national identity — that is internationalism with its United Nations, New World Order, etc,

Thus the breakdown of Christendom took place in two stages, by the Freemasons' famous "Solve et Coagula", or, "Break up and re-assemble". In the first stage, nationalism broke up Christendom into nations by turning natural identity against (Christian) unity. In the second stage, internationalism re-assembles the nations by turning (Judeo-masonic) unity against natural identity. NATO's onslaught in the Balkans is a clear example of this second stage in action, our Western "leaders" having long been controlled by Judeo-masonry.

Now we are in a position to answer the questions that must escape the nationalist. Why must the internationalists destroy the last vestiges of nationalism? Because Judeo-masonry, to make man into God, must make war on God and on the human nature that God made, and which can always lead back to God. But nationalism is natural, insofar as it respects and follows the God-given differences between races, continents and nations which are at least as real as the differences between all the brothers and sisters in one family. For just as God meant all these differences to complement one another in the harmony of a united family, so He obviously meant the different races and nations to look after one another in the completeness of the human family of mankind. Therefore internationalism must wipe out these national differences which tend to recreate a natural order, and it must smash to pieces any nationalist resistance, as in Serbia.

But how can internationalism succeed in such an unnatural enterprise? By appealing precisely to men's natural sense of the unity of mankind, and to a lingering nostalgia for the unity of Christendom. Neither unity is possible without Christ, as Napoleon and Hitler discovered when both strove to imitate Charlemagne, but the striving remains. And that is why the media's nonsensical rhetoric about "human rights" in Kosovo nevertheless deceives people. Men always have a sense of their natural unity to be appealed to, however artificial the appeal.

In conclusion, this war in the Balkans represents the outright enemies of God making war on, so to speak, His half-friends. Now it may seem better to be Christ's half-friend than his outright enemy, so nationalism may seem preferable to liberalism But Our Lord himself said that with him there is no such thing as half-and-half friendship. We cannot serve two masters. With him it is all or nothing. That is why nationalism without Christ is doomed to fail. That is why nationalist Serbia does not save the answer to NATO unless it seriously returns to Christ. That is why Christ is allowing in the modern world one worse horror after another to make us turn to him. Either we seriously convert, or it will be a third World War, such as will make the first two pale in comparison. NATO may be playing games, but Our Lord is not! Not "Get the US out of the UN", but "United States, United States, convert to the Lord thy God!"

The world needs Christ, Christ needs priests, priests need seminaries. Dear friends, thank you for your grand support through the month of April.

Most sincerely yours in Our Lord,

Theological study of the consecration of four bishops in Econe

April 2, 1999

Dear Friends and Benefactors,

To this day there must be many good Catholic souls longing to follow Archbishop Lefebvre or his Society of St. Pius X, but who hesitate to do so because they feel he went against Catholic principles, especially when he made four bishops in Ecône, Switzerland, on June 30,1988. Let such souls read a theological study of the consecrations that appeared three months ago in the Italian bi-weekly, "Si Si No No", and many may hesitate no longer. The article's first part proves that those episcopal consecrations were even a duty for the Archbishop, the second part proves that the Pope's explicit prohibition made no difference to that duty!

Not that the Archbishop himself did not know what he was doing. He explained himself clearly and often. Nor that Catholic souls following him then and since have not known what they were doing, because all along they have recognized the true Catholic bishop. "I am the good shepherd", says Our Lord, "and I know mine and mine know me" (Jn X,14).

The problem is rather that since in the circumstances of the 1970's and 1980's the Archbishop had to break a number of the Church's normal rules in order to maintain the Society of St. Pius X and in particular to consecrate four bishops, then it always looks as though he had the Catholic rule-book against him. And this is what made - and makes - so many Catholics hesitate. At last, the article of "Hirpinus" in "Si Si No No" has gone deep into those rule-books and shown, in a way I think nobody has shown before, that the Archbishop's action was fully in conformity with the truest principles of Catholic theology and Canon Law.

It stands to reason. After all, how could the Archbishop's work have borne so much good fruit if it was out of line with Catholic principles? That makes no sense. Yet to this day enemies of his Society, even conservatives whose survival is one of his fruits, cast in the Society's teeth the Catholic rule-book: "Where the Pope is, there the Church is", "Catholics must obey the Pope", "Obedience is a virtue", etc., etc.. Let us with Hirpinus take a good look at the Catholic rules, however briefly.

The first major principle that comes into play is that while ordinary cases are dealt with by ordinary laws, cases out of the ordinary, or emergency cases, need to be dealt with by principles behind and above the ordinary laws. That is common sense. For instance, in front of the hospital there is normally no parking, but if I am rushing my wife to the emergency room, then I can park wherever there is a space.

Now if, as the Vatican claims, there is no emergency in the Catholic Church today, then of course there can be no appeal to higher principles. However, as Hirpinus points out, Popes Paul VI and John Paul II have themselves by moments admitted that there is a very serious problem in the post-Vatican II Church. Paul VI's references to the Church's "self-destruction" (Dec. 7, '68) and to the "smoke of Satan in the temple of God" (June 30, '72) are famous. Similarly in a speech quoted in the "Osservatore Romano" of Feb. 7, '81, John Paul II referred to the "upset, confusion, perplexity, even delusion" of a "great part" of Christians. So Hirpinus' article is not for those who deny there is a post-conciliar emergency, rather it is for those who recognize the emergency, but fail to see how the episcopal consecrations were justified by that emergency.

The whole first part of the article examines then what are the duties and powers of a bishop in an emergency. Grave spiritual need is that of any soul whose Catholic faith or morals are threatened. Extreme spiritual need is that of any soul virtually unable to save itself, without help. Grave general or public spiritual need is where many souls are being threatened in their faith or morals, for instance where heresy is being spread in public. Today numberless Catholics are being threatened in their faith and morals by the public spread of neo-modernism, which is the re-invigorated "synthesis of all heresies". So today the Catholic Church is filled with grave general or public spiritual need.

Now wherever there is grave public spiritual need, the Catholic theologians teach that the situation is equivalent to that of extreme individual spiritual need, because for instance in a grave general need, many individuals will be in extreme need. So what a bishop or priest may or must do in an individual's extreme need, he may or must do in grave general need, like today's.

Now all legitimate pastors are bound in JUSTICE to help souls in a state of need, but if these pastors fail for whatever reason, then in CHARITY anyone else is bound to help who can, notably other bishops or priests. These latter will have no normal Church jurisdiction over souls coming under other pastors, but, by their ordination as bishops or priests charity includes for them a duty of state to help as they can. Now as the duty of charity binds under pain of mortal sin to help an individual neighbour in extreme need (especially spiritual), so it binds gravely to help a people in grave need (see above), even requiring if need be the sacrifice of life, reputation or property (Archbishop Lefebvre certainly sacrificed his reputation!).

If then today's neo-modernist errors and heresies are being put forward, or silently approved, or at least left unopposed, by the legitimate pastors themselves, Pope and bishops and priests, it follows that today's state of general need is without hope of relief from the legitimate pastors, in which case any other pastors are, by their ordination which empowers them to give spiritual relief, gravely bound in charity to help such needy souls as best they can (Just as, if a husband refuses to look after his family, the wife under him must supply as best she can, so if a Pope refuses to look after the Church, a bishop under him must supply as best he can).

And what gives such emergency pastors the right (or jurisdiction) to supply for the legitimate pastors? The grave need of many Catholics. The Church teaches that according as needy souls resort to emergency pastors, so these pastors receive from the Church emergency, or "supplied", jurisdiction. For as in a (genuine!) physical emergency all property belongs to all men, so in a spiritual emergency all episcopal and priestly powers are at the disposal of all souls. Divine and natural law then override normal Church law restricting jurisdiction, otherwise too many souls would be eternally lost. Jurisdiction is for souls, not souls for jurisdiction.

Now this principle of emergency rights, or "supplied jurisdiction", applies also to the case of a bishop consecrating bishops without the Pope's approval, because of grave public need. Certainly Christ instituted Peter as head of His Church, with the fullest possession of Church power to govern souls, towards eternal life. But that power, while wielded by Peter, is owned by Christ. It is to benefit souls, not its possessor. It is to save souls, not damn them. As for the machinery of Peter's control of the consecration of bishops, Christ left it flexible, so that Peter could, down the ages, tighten or loosen that machinery according as different historical circumstances would require for the good of the Church. Medieval popes tightened it, as did Pius XII because of a problem in China, but the Church has approved of Eusebius of Samosate consecrating bishops without the Pope's permission in the 4th century. Therefore if a Pope by his fallibility were to tighten that control to the grave harm of souls, the Church would supply jurisdiction for a bishop to take that consecration into his own hands, as did Archbishop Lefebvre. For the manner of episcopal consecrations is a matter not of divine law, but of human Church law, allowing for the exceptions possible in all human Church law.

Objection: but Eusebius of Samosate consecrated bishops without but not against, the Pope's express will. How could Archbishop Lefebvre go against the known and expressed "No" of the Pope? This question takes up the second part of Hirpinus' article. The answer flows from the principles laid out in the first part: however much the Pope said "No", he could not exonerate the Archbishop from his higher duty in charity to help souls in grave and general need.

Firstly, as to the subject, charity looks to the need, not to the cause of the need. When a road accident happens, helping the injured comes first, questions come later. Charity binds whoever can succour souls in grave need to do so, even if, especially if, legitimate Superiors are causing that need.

Secondly, as to the Superior, if he refuses to help souls in grave need, he has no power to bind others from doing so, any more than a husband refusing to provide for his children has power to bind his wife from doing so. The Pope is no exception to this rule, because while his authority is unlimited from below, it is limited from above by divine law, natural and positive, which binds gravely in charity whoever can to succour souls in need. Archbishop Lefebvre was uniquely able, by being a bishop refusing neo-modernism, to succour souls wishing to remain Catholic.

Thirdly, as to the situation, it is natural to necessity to know no law, or, to place the subject in the impossibility of obeying the lower law, because the subject could only do so by disobeying a higher law. The Pope as Superior is no exception because even he comes under divine law. And if it is he who creates the necessity, as does John Paul II by favouring neo-modernism, then it is the Superior himself who is making it impossible for his subject to obey him!

Notice however that whosoever disobeys in an emergency is disputing neither the authority nor its lawful exercise, but merely its unlawful exercise. He is not judging the lower law to be bad but merely inapplicable in the given emergency. Thus Archbishop Lefebvre contested the Pope's right to control episcopal consecrations not in general, but only in the particular emergency of the grave need of souls for the Society of St. Pius X to survive his own imminent death. The Church's supreme law is the salvation of souls, to which the law of papal primacy must, if necessary, give way. The Catholic's supreme virtue is charity, not obedience.

Therefore as soon as the Archbishop had prudently established that divine law was entering into play, he was not only entitled but even bound to disregard the Pope's express prohibition. For when divine law came into play, the Archbishop had to consider not the Superior's will which may be what it may be, but his power, which is fixed by Catholic theology and law. These say that once the emergency is reasonably proved, the subject may and must act on his own authority without recourse to the Superior, because the emergency need firstly to obey God makes that recourse irrelevant, because even if the Superior wanted to bind his subject against God, he could have no power to do so.

In conclusion, Archbishop Lefebvre was bound in charity to help souls, once they were in grave need with no hope of relief from their lawful superiors. He was bound by his episcopal powers to consecrate bishops to ensure for many needy souls the doctrine and sacraments owed to souls by the Church for their salvation. He was absolutely bound not to heed the Pope's "No", because by so doing he would have sinned gravely against the higher duty of charity. By consecrating bishops despite that "No", he neither denied the Pope's primacy nor in any real sense disobeyed the Pope's authority which cannot oppose divine law.

That is only the skeleton of Hirpinus' article. Its muscle consists in a mass of quotations from the most respected Catholic theologians, saints and lawyers. Of course! Catholic principles are in line with common sense, and Archbishop Lefebvre acted in line with both. Praise be to God! Make sure to read the complete article when it appears in English in the Angelus. Truth is mighty, and will prevail. Blessed are the souls who never took scandal from the Archbishop!

As for world events, our sins have deserved much tribulation. Pray mainly that souls be saved.

Most sincerely yours in Christ,

Clinton's aquittal and the degradation of morals

March 6,1999

Dear Friends and Benefactors,

When the United States Senate voted last month to acquit President Clinton of crimes of which all the known evidence had until then made him guilty, it was a sign of the times, marking an extraordinary degradation in the public life of the leading nation of the Western world. However, rather than heap blame on the sign, let us consider the times. In what does the degradation consist? Who is mainly responsible? What is its purpose?

The degradation consists essentially in the fact that instead of good accusing evil, it is now as though evil accuses good. Instead of decent standards being accepted while the facts are in dispute, now the indecent facts are widely accepted while the standards are in dispute. In this sense, what the Senate did last month is merely the culmination (for the moment) of a process of overthrowing old values. This process has been going on for a long time but on this occasion it broke out in spectacular fashion. Again and again during the last six years, "decent" Americans must have said to themselves, "But the public can't stand for this! The people will react against that!" But the reaction never came. Again and again such Americans have had to lick their wounds. It is as if the old moral standards no longer applied. The people seemed to rejoice in their being blown away.

Here are two examples. Firstly, when President Nixon was nearly impeached in 1974, the New York Stock Exchange fell disastrously. When Clinton was really impeached in 1998, it hardly wavered. That represents a very different public attitude. Second symptom: when the private adultery of an old-breed American politician becomes public, it can still destroy his career, because he admits it is wrong. But no adultery of any new-breed politician can give leverage to a blackmailer because then it is virtually a badge of honour. We are, as Americans say, in a completely new ball-game.

The next question is, who is mainly responsible for this enormous change in morals, merely shown forth in politics? For an answer let us return to the recent decision of the Senate. Was the system responsible? For instance, some people would say that the whole episode was just typical of the United States. Well, it may be true that the Puritanism rooted in the American soul twists out of true all kinds of moral reactions here, but can it be said that the moral rot is markedly worse in the U.S.A. than in many other Western nations, especially those repudiating a Catholic past which the United States never enjoyed? Surely not.

Then maybe the systematic liberalism of the U.S. Constitution was the problem in Clinton's acquittal? Now it is certain that the U.S. Constitution is not the all-saving remedy that some patriots pretend it to be, but in this case the impeachment process that it contains would have worked well, had it been operated by men whose first concern was the truth. As Catholics have always known, Constitutions are only worth what is in the hearts and minds of the men operating them. "Madam, you have a Republic, if you can keep it", said Benjamin Franklin on emerging from the Convention that forged the U.S. Constitution. This recent acquittal showed that today's Americans, by what they have in their hearts and minds, are fast losing their republic. See in the enclosed flyer what Donoso Cortés said to his fellow Spaniards 150 years ago on the same theme.

Then is systematic democracy the problem, which made the constitutionally appointed Senators bow under the pressure of the opinion polls? No doubt public opinion did put the Senators under pressure, but did it force them to acquit Clinton? Of course not. Many senators voted against acquittal. In conclusion, as Catholics should know, systems are not the problem, but people. What people were responsible for this acquittal?

It is interesting in this respect to compare the acquittal of Clinton with the release of Barabbas (Mt XXVII, 1523). When Pontius Pilate released this "notorious prisoner", there were three parties responsible. Pilate himself bore the official responsibility, because only he could give the order for Barabbas to be released. The "chief priests and ancients" bore the leading responsibility, because it is they who persuaded the crowd to cry out for the release of Barabbas, and to raise such a tumult as made Pilate give way. The crowd bore the ultimate responsibility, because when Pilate washed his hands in front of them to protest that he was innocent of the blood of "this just man", i.e. Jesus, the whole people answering said, "His blood be upon us and upon our children".

Official responsibility, leading responsibility, ultimate responsibility - which was the main responsibility? Surely not Pilate's, because he would obviously not have released Barabbas or condemned Jesus had he not been put under severe pressure by the crowd and its leaders. The responsibility of the conspiratorial chief priests and ancients (cf. Jn XI, 47-53 for their conspiracy) in the release of Barabbas and death of Jesus is overwhelming. However, without the crowd, they were powerless to force Pilate's hand, and they could not force the crowd, therefore the main responsibility must be that of the crowd, which freely chose to follow those evil leaders.

For just as the most skilful horse-rider can only work with the horse that he has beneath him, so the most skilful politician, be he democrat or aristocrat or king, can still only work with the people that he has beneath him. In the case of Barabbas' release, God punished both leaders and people, with the destruction of Jerusalem in 70 AD, and then with that curse they had called down upon themselves, and from which only those blessed few escape who call down the Precious Blood as a laver of regeneration.

Now let us apply these principles to Clinton's acquittal. Official responsibility lies obviously with the Senate. Like Pilate, they did not want to handle the case but were forced to do so. Like Pilate, they might have preferred to judge in accordance with justice and truth, but they chose to yield to the cries of the opinion polls, and so they bear an inescapable responsibility for the sentence of acquittal.

However, leading responsibility lies with the media which mould public opinion in modern democracies, and with the money-men who control those media. Why are the media so powerful? Because the liberals said to God, "We can do without you, all we need to run our affairs is an informed democracy", and the Lord God replied, "Alright, see where democracy by godless information gets you", and we have government by vile media, vile because moving all the time away from God. As for the money-men controlling the media that agitate the crowd, they are the direct successors of the chief-priests and ancients, and like them, their prime motive in this acquittal is to destroy Jesus. Here is one of their spokesmen, as quoted in the "Wanderer" of last Dec. 24: "We are in a culture war... a vote against impeachment of Clinton is not a vote for Clinton but a vote against fundamentalism and the pro-life movement. The anti-Clinton alliance is the forces of evil! - evil! - genuine evil!".

Nevertheless, even if the money-men wield enormous power by their money and their media, still, like the chief-priests and ancients, they could not exercise successful pressure on the Senators except through the people, and even with their media they could not force the people to support Clinton. Therefore the ultimate responsibility for Clinton's acquittal lay with the American people, who, when all is said and done, have the media and the leaders and the President that they deserve. The people want the President they now have because, like them, he defies the Ten Commandments, and he makes them feel good doing so.

That is why, to come to our third question, for leaders and for people the real purpose of the Clinton acquittal, as of the release of Barabbas, is to get rid of Jesus. The Clinton acquittal is a battle not only in a culture war but in a religious war. The people want to sin. They want money, materialism and all the pleasures money can buy. They want no restraints upon their sinful ways. This is what the money-men and corrupt politicians give them. This is why they want power to the money-men and to corrupt politicians. This is why Barabbas was released and Clinton was acquitted.

However, all is not lost, far from it. Even in Jerusalem's darkest hour under the "power of darkness" (Lk XXII, 53) when Our Lord was being betrayed and crucified, still there was a Veronica, a Simon of Cyrene, a Joseph of Arimathea, and an unwavering Mother of God. Amidst the crowd baying for the blood of Our Lord, still there will have been single souls or families not following the wicked crowd, but looking up to God, trusting God, and begging Him for the grace not to abandon Him. Nobody can force us to follow the movement of the crowd, to desire money, to expose ourselves to the media, to live sinfully. If only Catholics were Catholic and truly renounced the world and the flesh and the devil, the money-men and the media would rapidly lose their power. The more we analyze their power, the more we see how dependent it is on sin, which depends on my free will and the lack of grace.

Then let me pray to recover or to re-inforce grace. Let me pray quietly and steadily, each day at least five, preferably fifteen, Mysteries of the Holy Rosary. Let me get to Mass as often as possible, and to Confession. Let me stop watching television, and read a minimum of newspapers. Let me read Catholic classics, pre-Council from TAN Publishers (Rockford, IL), post-Council from the Angelus Press (Kansas City, MO). And let me trust in God, who even if he has to destroy Jerusalem, will make all work for good to those who love Him (Rom VIII, 28). We are in His hands.

Men, also make use of the Ignatian Exercises available here at the seminary, the first just after Easter, as per the enclosed flyer. And use the courses of Family Doctrine, and Literature. Catholic lives need Catholic minds, Catholic minds need Catholic truths.

And may you all have a grace-filled Holy Week and Eastertide.

Most sincerely yours in Our Lord Jesus Christ,

Can Cardinal Ratzinger be trusted?

February 9, 1999

Dear Friends and Benefactors,

Can Cardinal Ratzinger be trusted? Conservative Catholics tend to think so. "Nice" Traditional Catholics wish to think so. "Nasty" Traditionalists think not. Who is right?

The question arose in agonising form in 1988 when Archbishop Lefebvre was negotiating, principally with the Cardinal, to obtain bishops for Catholic Tradition. Conservatives blamed him then (and still do) for not, finally, trusting Rome. Ten years later Conservatives found themselves facing the same question when the Cardinal appealed to them to trust Rome in the matter of the liturgy. Do they now follow through on their own policy of trust?

The occasion was the Conservative Catholics' gathering in Rome last October to celebrate the 10th anniversary of the Pope's Motu Proprio "Ecclesia Dei" of July 1988, condemning Archbishop Lefebvre but apparently favouring the pre-Vatican II liturgy. Here is a fair summary of the speech, quoted in full in the December issue of "Inside the Vatican", in which the Cardinal appealed for the Conservatives' trust:

-Despite the positive fruits of "Ecclesia Dei", said the Cardinal, there is amongst Conciliar Catholics much distrust of you Conservative (Ecclesia Dei) Catholics, because of your attachment to the old liturgy. This need not be, if only both sides will abide by the letter (as opposed to the so-called "spirit") of the Second Vatican Council.

- For on the one hand, the Cardinal went on, the text of the Council's Constitution on the liturgy does not promote the wild excesses of the so-called "creative" liturgists who, by pushing the text too far in one direction only, have in the name of community worship virtually emptied out the priesthood, sacrifice, all mystery and sacredness. Quite to the contrary that text never forbade the Tridentine Mass, it does not mention Mass facing the people, it encourages Latin. In fact when a celebration of the New Mass is faithful to Pope Paul VI's Missal, it is closer to the Old Mass than it is to any of the wild new liturgies.

-On the other hand the same text, following the admirable Liturgical Movement which led up to the Council's Constitution, does call for more active participation of the people in the liturgy, as opposed to the excessively private and individual following of Mass which had become the norm for Mass-goers before the Council.

-Therefore, concluded the Cardinal, a new Liturgical Movement to restore a truly liturgical unity-in-diversity of Conciliarists and Conservatives is not something that you Conservatives must distrust. Quote: "Dear friends, I would like to encourage you not to lose patience - to keep trusting..."

Thus Cardinal Ratzinger seems to be suggesting that Rome is pondering another liturgical reform which would give us a Mass neither wildly new nor completely old, and he seems to be asking lovers of the old liturgy to wait patiently for this reform of the reform, and to trust Rome meanwhile. Now the Cardinal seems to be a "nice" man, and few Cardinals in Rome say so many favourable things about the old liturgy as he does. Yet can Rome, even as represented by him, be trusted in the matter of the liturgy?

Alas, the answer must be no. Why?

Because while the Cardinal's heart may be open to the Tridentine Mass, his mind is blocked, and in a man of his calibre, the mind rules the heart. His sympathy with the old Mass is relatively superficial, his opposition to it is profound. All this is clear to see in the autobiographical memoirs for the first 50 years of his life, 1927-1957, which he published two years ago in a little book called "Milestones", available in the USA from Ignatius Press, San Francisco. The matter is of interest to all Catholics, because it shows how crippled is even the seeming best of today's Romans when it comes to defending the Faith. Despite their apparent benevolence they cannot defend what they no longer understand.

Josef Ratzinger was born of humble but devout parents in 1927 in a deeply Catholic part of the world, South Germany, close to the Austrian frontier. Youngest of three children in a tranquil home, he grew up with a natural love of God, Church, family and homeland which never left him. He describes how he was also indelibly marked in childhood by the Traditional (then normal) Catholic liturgy, because the great Church ceremonies of the different seasons of the year impressed deep in his soul the sense of the Catholic mysteries.

Here is why the Cardinal has so little sympathy for the so-called "spirit of Vatican II" in the name of which the Church's liturgy has been turned into a wasteland. Towards the end of "Milestones" are a few pages severely condemning the Novus Ordo Missal of 1969 as a "self-made", or artificial, liturgy, pages which Conservative Catholics love to quote and which many a Traditional Catholic could not have written better. No wonder the Cardinal seemed to receive Conservatives kindly in Rome last October! No wonder he might tempt Traditionalists out of their Traditional fortress!

Then where is the Cardinal's problem? Back to "Milestones". After his happy childhood overshadowed by the rise of Nazism and the wartime years marked by its collapse, in 1945 he entered near Munich the re-constituted Major Seminary to begin his studies for the priesthood, where he says (p.42), "We wanted not only to do theology in the narrower sense, but to listen to the voices of man today" - here for the Catholic reader a red light begins to wink! For nobody may mind any brave young man wishing to grapple with horrors which have just nearly engulfed his world - but what Catholic can conceive of his Church's eternal theology as being somehow too narrow to embrace modem man?

So the young Ratzinger plunges with enthusiasm into the study of modern philosophers. “By contrast, I had difficulties in penetrating the thought of Thomas Aquinas, whose crystal-clear logic seemed to me too closed in on itself, too impersonal and ready-made". For, says Ratzinger, he and his fellow-seminarians were presented with "a rigid neo-scholastic thomism that was simply too far afield from my own questions... We, being young, were questioners above all" (p.44).

Now it is all very well pleading youth, but since when was the point of questions anything other than to find answers? Is searching better than finding? That is the modem mentality. Either Ratzinger's teachers did not appreciate the Catholic truth of St. Thomas, or Ratzinger did not appreciate his teachers, whichever it be or both, this young philosophy student is missing out on truth. His brilliant mind is pursuing something else - its own satisfaction upon its own (modern) terms? What will he do when he comes to theology? The crucial Chapter VI tells.

To begin theological studies in 1947, he asks to go not to the diocesan seminary, but instead to the Munich University Theological Faculty "to become more fully familiar with the intellectual debates of our time" (p.47), so as to become later a professional theologian. But, again, are modern (university) questions really more valuable than the Church's (seminary) answers? Does this student have a sense of truth? The star teacher at the Faculty, whose "liberalism restricted by dogma" deeply appealed by its modern-ancient balance to the young Ratzinger (p.52), was a certain Professor Maier, whose "liberal-historical method" in approaching Scripture "opened up dimensions of the text that were no longer perceived by the all-too-predetermined dogmatic reading" (p.52)! In other words, history's relativising had more to give to our young theologian than dogma's absolutes? His mind is at sea!

For he is thinking with the mind not of the Catholic Church but of these humanly brilliant German thinkers, about whom he says, "German arrogance perhaps also contributed a little to our belief that we knew what was what better than `those down there' (i.e. in Rome)" (p.58). Ratzinger and his teachers would submit to a decision of Rome, but basically they felt themselves superior. Chapter VI of "Milestones" abounds in quotations to illustrate the downfall of our pious young Bavarian - intellectual pride.

The pious heart is still there, but it is completely out-weighed and out-gunned for Ratzinger by the dazzling intellectualism of Germany's top modernists, all of whom he will meet and befriend when, after being ordained priest in 1951, he embarks in 1952 upon the academic career he has hoped for. For the next 25 years he is professing theology in Germany in one prestigious seminary or university after another. Let us take a look at how his mind is now working as he sets out to teach (p. 108, 109).

In 1953, to obtain his "Habilitation", or final qualification to profess theology, he describes how he prepared a thesis on the great medieval Doctor, St. Bonaventure. Here is Ratzinger's argument, in which he says he still believes (comments in brackets):

The word "revelation" can mean either the act of revealing or the content revealed [true]. Whereas we usually use the word to mean the content revealed [true], Bonaventure uses it to mean the act of revealing [maybe]. Therefore "revelation" means the act of revealing ["Therefore"? Who made Bonaventure dictator of meanings?]. But there is no act of revealing without someone to reveal to [true, but wait for it ...] . Therefore Church Revelation [act or content??] always includes as an essential element the Church being revealed to. Therefore Revelation, Scripture and Tradition [now Ratzinger has definitely slidden back from act to content!] are all incomplete without the Church or persons being revealed to. Therefore whatever of religion comes to us from God must be no ready-made and finalized product or content such as Catholicism was always supposed to be, but it must incorporate the in-put of us modern men. In brief, in the old days God told men what was in the Catholic religion, but that religion fell dead. Now man tells God what is in the Catholic religion, and religion is again living!

From 1953 to 1988 to 1998 we can see that Cardinal Ratzinger's thinking has not changed. In 1988, in the name of "living Tradition", he did his honest best to stop Archbishop Lefebvre from going into "schism" with his "dead Tradition". In 1998 he did his honest best to keep Conservative Catholics loyal to Rome by trust in a new liturgical reform movement which will of course actively involve living modern man, because without that living in-put the liturgy, like Revelation and Tradition, will be dead. But the excessively private Tridentine Mass is too fixed and ready-made to allow for any such in-put. Therefore the Cardinal's Rome can be trusted not to preserve the Tridentine Mass.

Yet all the while the Cardinal in his heart genuinely appreciates the incomparable sacredness and mystery of the old liturgy (pp. 18-20, 146-149). Alas, that liturgy never took a hold of his head, so it cannot govern his thinking or action. Unless or until he changes his thinking, i.e. doctrine, the Tridentine Mass is bound to remain for him a sentimental side-line. In other words, prior to the Council Josef Ratzinger was a ring-leader of Fiftiesists or Bing Crosby Catholics. Maybe his heart was "dreaming of a white Christmas", but his head was ready filled with the poison of man-centered Vatican II.

Your Eminence, if ideas did not matter, you might be a good Catholic, but since the virtue of faith is seated in the mind and not in the heart, then so long as your mind swings between Tradition and modernity you are, despite yourself, in your position as Guardian of the Faith, a terrible enemy of the Catholic Church.

We might wish to trust you, but we cannot.

Men, remember that there are 5-day Igantian Spiritual Exercises available for you at the Seminary from April 5 to 10. These Exercises are an incomparable means of truly renewing Catholic Life.

With all good wishes and blessings for a fruitful Lent,

Sincerely yours in Christ,